Avian influenza spreads to Colorado dairy farm
Sampling of beef cattle and pigs recommended
29 April 2024
4 minute read
By: Additional tests of milk showed that pasteurisation killed the avian influenza virus, federal health officials said on Friday, as Colorado became the ninth US state to report an infected dairy herd, reported Reuters.
Federal lawmakers urged the Biden administration to further contain the virus' spread as tests showed one in five U.S. commercial milk samples contained remnants of the virus, suggesting the outbreak is more widespread than previously thought.
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) late on Friday said preliminary results from gold-standard PCR testing showed pasteurization killed the virus in milk and baby formula. It did not say how many milk products it had tested but added that it plans to do more testing on 297 products from 38 states.
One person, a Texas farm worker, has been confirmed to have bird flu and suffered conjunctivitis in the current outbreak following exposure to dairy cows. Both the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the World Health Organization said on Friday the current overall public health risk is low, but is higher for those with exposure to infected animals.
The US Department of Agriculture confirmed milking cows in Colorado tested positive, following earlier infections in Texas, Kansas, Michigan, Ohio, Idaho, New Mexico, North Carolina and South Dakota.
Congress members' push for a stronger response added pressure on federal agriculture and health authorities still seeking to confirm how the H5N1 virus is spreading and its potential risks to people, one month after the first detection in a Texas dairy herd.
An analysis of US Department of Agriculture (USDA) data by a University of Arizona scientist offers new evidence that the first known H5N1 outbreak in dairy cattle is more far-reaching than the 34 herds in nine states that have officially tested positive.
"Containing this before it spreads among humans is critical. Given lessons learned from COVID, this federal response is insufficient," Republican US Senator Mitt Romney said in a post on X.
Some lawmakers, including Romney, have made a bipartisan push to reauthorize legislation known as the Pandemic and All Hazards Preparedness Act that lapsed last year and is aimed at bolstering the nation's response to pandemics and other public health threats. The recent spread of avian influenza and the detection of H5N1 genetic materials in milk have increased some calls for action.
The virus in the human case is significantly different from the avian influenza virus samples taken from infected cattle that were made public by government officials last weekend, said Michael Worobey, an evolutionary biologist from the University of Arizona.
The difference between the genetic sequences of the worker's virus and the 239 other samples provided indicate that "this was a very longstanding, widespread epidemic," he told Reuters.
The Texas Animal Health Commission said it did not receive the location of the worker's farm or obtain samples of that herd to test because of the person's confidentiality.
"I think the sequences out there probably aren't representative of everything that's circulating," said Dr. Richard Webby, a virologist at St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital in Memphis.
A CDC spokesperson said in an email "there are always some subtle changes in genetic sequences when flu viruses move from host-to-host," but said data points to the virus emerging from birds to infect cows and then transmission to the human.
Traces of virus found in US milk
One in five commercial milk samples tested in a nationwide survey contained particles of the H5N1 virus, the FDA said late on Thursday. The agency said there is no reason to believe the virus found in milk poses a risk to human health and on Friday described results of the new tests.
"This says this virus has largely saturated dairy cattle throughout the country," said Michael Osterholm, an infectious disease expert at the University of Minnesota.
Many infectious disease experts and government officials have said they believe the pasteurization process will inactivate the virus, also known as avian influenza.
"I'm not worried about the milk itself," said Samuel Alcaine, associate professor, of food science at Cornell University. "It does indicate that the virus is more widespread among dairies than we had previously thought."
Osterholm said the US should be doing much more sampling, in both dairy and beef cattle, as well as pigs.
Democratic US Senator Tammy Baldwin of Wisconsin, a significant dairy state with no reported cases, has urged the USDA to "quickly deploy additional resources in states that have the opportunity to prevent the disease from entering herds."
The White House has said that it is monitoring the avian flu situation, launching an "immediate response team" to ensure the safety of the nation’s food supply, monitor trends to mitigate risk and prevent the virus' spread.
Starting on Monday, the USDA will require dairy cows to test negative for bird flu before they are moved across state lines.
In Indiana, officials are weighing their own potential restrictions, such as testing within the state, though it has no confirmed cases, said Bret Marsh, the state veterinarian.
"We're taking a look here at the state level to see what we may need to do," he said on a conference call.
